PDA

View Full Version : Non-Traditional Education?


cara
01-08-2010, 02:25 PM
I'm curious about everyone's childhood education. Were you educated in a non-traditional school like a montessori or a Waldorf School? Were you home schooled? What was it like for you? How did the experience help/hinder you in later years?

I'll start: My parents enrolled me in a montessori pre-school and day care for a few years before I started kindergarten in a non-traditional grade school program. In grade school, we had very small class sizes and called our teachers by their first names. Our parents were required to help out in the classroom many hours each year. We were not graded and rarely had homework. Field trips were monthly occurances and we spent hours each day playing and creating artwork and learning on our own terms and at our own pace. Often, classrooms had more than 1 grade level. For instance, I had the same teacher for 4th, 5th, and 6th grade. In addition to frequently tutoring younger students, we also mentored differently abled students in a program called "Share & Care," since our school was next door to the district's special education program. I had to take three different shuttle buses to school and spent nearly three hours each day getting to/from school. Thankfully, there was a number of other kids in my neighborhood who also participated in the program. We would sit together and defend each other when the other kids would start picking on us for being different.

It's safe to say the transition from grade school to a traditional, public junior high school was not easy. The kids I previously spent seven years with were in different schools all over the district or in private schools. I was smart and did well academically so homework was still a rareity for me. However, I was not used to such big class sizes and rigid rules and structure, including bells between classes and the most dreaded class of all--gym class. Socially, I was a bit awkward, but who isn't during at that stage of life?

So, that's a little about my experience. How about yours?

Corkey
01-09-2010, 04:12 PM
I'm so old none of these programs were available. I started kindergarden at 4 1/2, got all my points to graduate college prep at 16, stuck around for one more year to play sports, graduated with my class and went to college while in the AF.
I can honestly say I never wanted for an education, it was there for me, I did as well as I possibly could, and continue to learn something new every day.
Public school, K-12

Crone
01-10-2010, 12:43 AM
I think that not everyone is a cookie cutter. So alternative education programs are great!

Crone

cara
01-10-2010, 02:06 AM
I think that not everyone is a cookie cutter. So alternative education programs are great!

Crone

I 100% agree! :)

cara
01-10-2010, 02:10 AM
I'm so old none of these programs were available. I started kindergarden at 4 1/2, got all my points to graduate college prep at 16, stuck around for one more year to play sports, graduated with my class and went to college while in the AF.
I can honestly say I never wanted for an education, it was there for me, I did as well as I possibly could, and continue to learn something new every day.
Public school, K-12

I like this. Life just wouldn't be the same if we didn't learn something new every day. :)

Selenay
01-10-2010, 03:01 AM
What is "traditional" education?

A public school in the neighborhood?

A public school outside of the neighborhood?

A public school with selective admissions?

Toughy
01-10-2010, 09:46 AM
I was born in 1952...........there were no 'alternative education' programs. It was public school and in my home town that was the only game in town.

I really had no idea private school existed until I was in the 9th grade and one of my best friends got pregnant and was shipped of to a private boarding school in Phoenix.

MsDemeanor
01-10-2010, 11:47 AM
The military moved us all the time and always mid-school year, so I was in a new school many Februarys and then sometimes changed schools again in September (going from 6th to 7th grade for example) and sometimes they were civilian schools and sometimes they were on-base schools. In total, I went to 11 different schools between K and 9 and one high school. Does that fall under "traditional" or "non-traditional"?

BornBronson
02-21-2010, 03:18 PM
If traditional schooling means staying in one city,town,ect,until you graduated from high school.Then no,mine was very non-traditional.

Btw,I believe in home schooling is the best form of education.

I mean,just look how I turned out.

What?

Words
02-21-2010, 03:54 PM
Two of my three kids spent about two years in a Waldorf School. From a social point of view, it was wonderful. Academically? A disaster. Perhaps if they'd been there from the get go, but they hadn't, they'd been in mainstream education so as far as they were concerned, going to a Waldorf school was like one big extended holiday. (Let's face it, how many kids would choose to do homework if they knew there was no 'punishment' for not doing it?)

So, did I do the right thing in sending them there? I think so, if for no other reason - they were the only Palestinian kids in what, until then, had been a school for Israeli kids - than it allowed them to form their own opinions about Israelis and to appreciate that not all Israelis are the enemy. BUT, I do feel - and I think the guilt surrounding this will stay with me forever - that from an academic educational point of view (rather than a 'life' educational point of view) I did them a huge disservice.

*Sigh.* Yet one more thing to feel guilty about. Ugh.

Words