Butch Femme Planet

Butch Femme Planet (http://www.butchfemmeplanet.com/forum/index.php)
-   The Butch Zone (http://www.butchfemmeplanet.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   "Stud" versus "Butch" (http://www.butchfemmeplanet.com/forum/showthread.php?t=5957)

Daywalker 11-04-2012 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Martina (Post 691922)
God, we sound white. I guess because, for the most part, we are. I guess my white privilege allows me to forget that sometimes.


I thought the same thing, but wasn't sure if it was just
my own perspective reading it that way, so thanks for out-louding it.

Folks who feel the need to buck any Identity due to their perspective
having already ruled it a minority term...should take a moment to marinate on why.

:daywalker:

Corkey 11-04-2012 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IslandScout (Post 691465)
Sometimes, though, "appropriating" is a way of subverting power dynamics in a cultural or social construct. Members of our community appropriate male pronouns. Gays and lesbians appropriate straight marriage rituals. And so on.

Sometimes appropriation is kind of thrilling.

Sorry been gone all day and this just hit me wrong.
*I* being a male in a female body have *appropriated* nothing. I am who I am, and I am Male. I'm sorry if this doesn't fit with the whole white privilege thing, but it is true none the less. Sometimes I wish folks would put away the microscope and learn that there are whole societies that live just fine, minus the privilege. If the UK isn't as knowledgeable about Studs, Aggressive, and other Pronouns, I would suggest it may be due to culture. Again, Culture is the apt usage of Pronouns that people use to express who they are to a society that hold them at arms length, with privilege.

Samurai Wanderer 11-05-2012 02:54 AM

Thanks for this thread, Girl On Fire :) I've been struggling with B-F terminologies in general, so it's helpful to see threads about these terms being discussed. While I see the sense of simply googling, it's a passive act. I find reading active discussions on the topic more interesting. Language and semantics are ever evolving, to reflect the people who use them. Aren't we the ones who collectively 'own' these terms, and who are most active in deepening and evolving the language that we use?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Girl_On_Fire (Post 691192)
I just happened to see 'stud' as meaning one thing. I had a picture of a prize stallion in my head. (*giggles*)

... I thought that's as good a meaning of 'stud' as any :cowboihorse:

Samurai Wanderer 11-05-2012 03:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 691715)
However, It is also my long time experience that self empowering labels are anathema to many within the wider 'gay' 'community' but not so much in the pan sexual kink 'community'. It is this that led me on my own path to individual gender expression. :|

I don't quite understand this part. Why would the gay community want to avoid self empowering labels? Aren't we in the business of self-empowering?

always2late 11-05-2012 03:27 AM

Growing up in a multi-cultural area of Brooklyn, I heard the term "papi" used, but it was primarily used in a straight setting. I'd also heard the term "stud"...again primarily in straight discourse. I never heard the terms "stud" "aggressive" or "papi" used in the LGBT context until I joined the LGBT club at my college. From my own experience, I found this to be more an issue of age than of diversity. I live, and work, in a very diverse community, however, it wasn't until I spent time with the 20-something age group that I heard the terms used frequently. Now...I'm not saying that the terms weren't, or haven't, been used in a cultural context for many years..just that I'd never heard them. I will say that, when I joined the club at my college, it made my heart sing to hear young butches, studs, aggressives, and every other self-identifier used with such freedom and pride! It has, and still does, make my heart leap a bit when I see the younger generation...those coming after me...embrace who they are with whatever ID they choose so freely and with such an unabashed sense of self. I admire them, I cheer for them, I support them...and I love them all. :)

Daktari 11-05-2012 06:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Samurai Wanderer (Post 692435)
I don't quite understand this part. Why would the gay community want to avoid self empowering labels? Aren't we in the business of self-empowering?

Yes 'we' are.
However I find that in the wider 'gay community' I encounter here in UK, including many of my 'gay' friends, folks don't use the labels we embrace here in the b/f world. Mostly I find the attitude to be "I'm just me, I don't need labels". I have observed that those who embrace labels are those who don't 'fit', into the wider gay 'community'.

It is my experience that most folks I come into contact with, homo or hetero, don't understand the need for self empowering, self identifying labels...until a patient person explains the need.

:chaplin:

Samurai Wanderer 11-05-2012 07:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 692465)
Yes 'we' are.
However I find that in the wider 'gay community' I encounter here in UK, including many of my 'gay' friends, folks don't use the labels we embrace here in the b/f world. Mostly I find the attitude to be "I'm just me, I don't need labels". I have observed that those who embrace labels are those who don't 'fit', into the wider gay 'community'.

It is my experience that most folks I come into contact with, homo or hetero, don't understand the need for self empowering, self identifying labels...until a patient person explains the need.

:chaplin:

It's been overwhelming to sift through and keep up with the labels, I had given up. After finding this community, it feels that for once, there are labels that I might be able to identify with. Thank you for explaining, I've never thought of labels as self-empowering, yet I'm beginning to feel it even if I can't explain why.

Daywalker 11-05-2012 06:09 PM


I've been thinking about this a lot,
and I'm glad the question came up.


I wanted to say that with every label comes the dreaded stereotype.

Yet, if we do not have a way to differentiate with 'labels' things
get cloudy for some. I like to think of these categories
as 'descriptors' rather than labels.

Well the emerging generations of Studs, Ags, Aggressives, Machas
etc., also deal with being stereotyped within the Community.

Just like Butch folks, Femme folks and all under the rainbow folks have.

I have 2 links to share for thought

One is a U-TooB channel from StudzLife101.

http://www.youtube.com/user/StudzLife101?feature=watch


The other is this video...



:daywalker:

ruffryder 11-05-2012 06:20 PM

AS for the term "papi"
 
I've only heard papi referred to for male identified individuals, gay or straight. My girl actually calls me papi = daddy. I also know mostly latin people, male and female, use the term to call younger latin males. . and guys call other guys papi too. At least here in Fl where I am. I'm sure when they use that term "papi" it's not in reference to daddy but instead a male they believe is good looking. Hence the term "papi chulo"

Daywalker 11-05-2012 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ruffryder (Post 692827)
I've only heard papi referred to for male identified individuals, gay or straight. My girl actually calls me papi = daddy. I also know mostly latin people, male and female, use the term to call younger latin males. . and guys call other guys papi too. At least here in Fl where I am. I'm sure when they use that term "papi" it's not in reference to daddy but instead a male they believe is good looking. Hence the term "papi chulo"


On the other hand, I have a friend of 22 years who is Hispanic and
whose Femme calls her Papi and/or Poppi...her preferred pronoun is She.

So does not Identify as a male.

It's all relative...to me.

:aslpeacelove:


:daywalker:

The_Lady_Snow 11-05-2012 06:39 PM

Cause I am to tired to type about it
 
>LINKYLOO<



"Excuse Me Sir"


All the shows are actually all very informative, you'll have to look them up on YOU TUBE to watch them.

Daywalker 11-05-2012 06:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The_Lady_Snow (Post 692841)
>LINKYLOO<



"Excuse Me Sir"


All the shows are actually all very informative, you'll have to look them up on YOU TUBE to watch them.

I know Q-Roc.

I heart Q-Roc.

:weedsmoke:

:daywalker:


The_Lady_Snow 11-05-2012 06:55 PM

Uh huh
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Daywalker (Post 692845)
I know Q-Roc.

I heart Q-Roc.

:weedsmoke:

:daywalker:



Me too, when ruffryder mentioned only the cis male version of Papi I remember how lucky I was to have been around a diverse POC queer experience. I really urge folks to read/listen to Q-Roc's stuff it's very informative.

I wish more POC gender variant folks would come to BFP to share experiences and culture.

julieisafemme 11-05-2012 07:31 PM

Excellent post Mr. Day. I think of butch, femme, papi and other descriptors as you said as identities. A woman spoke at a conference we went to and she said labels are what others apply to you and identites are what you use to express yourself. I thought this was a great way of putting it. Are labels and identities the same thing? I don't think they are.



Quote:

Originally Posted by Daywalker (Post 692818)

I've been thinking about this a lot,
and I'm glad the question came up.


I wanted to say that with every label comes the dreaded stereotype.

Yet, if we do not have a way to differentiate with 'labels' things
get cloudy for some. I like to think of these categories
as 'descriptors' rather than labels.

Well the emerging generations of Studs, Ags, Aggressives, Machas
etc., also deal with being stereotyped within the Community.

Just like Butch folks, Femme folks and all under the rainbow folks have.

I have 2 links to share for thought

One is a U-TooB channel from StudzLife101.

http://www.youtube.com/user/StudzLife101?feature=watch


The other is this video...



:daywalker:


Girl_On_Fire 11-05-2012 08:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daywalker (Post 692818)

I've been thinking about this a lot,
and I'm glad the question came up.


I wanted to say that with every label comes the dreaded stereotype.

Yet, if we do not have a way to differentiate with 'labels' things
get cloudy for some. I like to think of these categories
as 'descriptors' rather than labels.

Well the emerging generations of Studs, Ags, Aggressives, Machas
etc., also deal with being stereotyped within the Community.

Just like Butch folks, Femme folks and all under the rainbow folks have.

I have 2 links to share for thought

One is a U-TooB channel from StudzLife101.

http://www.youtube.com/user/StudzLife101?feature=watch


The other is this video...



:daywalker:

That was helpful, actually. Thank you. I think it's great this has turned into a real, diverse, cultural discussion. :)

txdoc 11-09-2012 06:17 PM



Another Perspective...

The_Lady_Snow 11-09-2012 06:23 PM

WTF
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by txdoc (Post 696488)


Another Perspective...



You're kidding me right?

What perspective is this?

Chancie 11-09-2012 06:42 PM

Because the narrator is so young,

I'm thinking about how I'd respond to one of my students.

With that lens, I want to have patience for her ignorance, but

Her 'Shut the fuck up' stance really bothers me.

It makes it impossible for me to try to disentangle her misconceptions.

MissItalianDiva 11-09-2012 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by txdoc (Post 696488)


Another Perspective...


I realize everyone has different perspectives but this whole video bothers me on so many different levels. I don't even know where to start so I think I will just end with WTF

Dude 11-09-2012 07:19 PM

but she's like totally been a lesbian for a year now

futch and stem<== strike them :hammer: from the record
thank you


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:16 AM.

ButchFemmePlanet.com
All information copyright of BFP 2018