I personally decided to start a thread to give rep to anyone who wanted it (or anyone who posted in the thread whether it was "for" rep or not). Everyone gets rep regardless of who they are or what they post. All very random and dada and silly.
If there are issues with the reputation point system itself, then that could be discussed, but I don't see how playing around with rep points in a thread where they are given out equally to every poster could be a problem. This thread has a total equality policy as far as my reps go.
