Quote:
Originally Posted by popcorninthesofa
I designed a beautiful memorial to be built there as well as others, and I shall believe to my death that a memorial should stay there.
|
What better memorial could there be for those that died than a community center that would fly in the face of the what people on *both* sides would be the preferred result. The jihadis would like nothing more than for this Muslim community center *not* be built. If it isn't, then they can look at their brethren and say, "see! Did we not tell you that all of America's promise of religious freedom does not apply to Muslims? Did we not try to pull the scales from your eyes that America, despite the honeyed words, does not truly welcome diversity? Here some of our brethren in America wanted to build a community center in a city where many Muslims live and it could not be done. Now do you believe that we must strike against America?" There are Christians who do not want this community center built because having a community center normalizes Muslims. It is one thing to get people to fear and ostracize Sharif, when he is nothing more than a collection of stereotypes made from a pastiche of movies from Lawrence of Arabia to the latest summer action shoot-em-up. It is quite another thing to get people to fear and ostracize Faud, the young father who takes his girls to the community center twice a week for swimming and who sits in the park playing chess.
The groups concerned about sharia law in America (which is just a smokescreen to justify a conclusion they've already arrived at) have as their selling point fear of Muslims. What's amazing about this is that it's not *just* this community center. In Tennessee there's a similar flap over a different Muslim community center. So what happens in New York has potential ramifications across the country *beyond* the public relations stupidity that denying the permit would be. If New York City, the most diverse city in the country, does not permit this community center then the folks in Tennessee will be emboldened in not permitting a community center or mosque built in their backyards. And that can spread like a wave.
One fascinating thing is that this is make all of these folks who are so quick to pronounce themselves more Constitutional-than-thou, is that it is forcing them to come out and say what many of us presumed they have meant all along vis a vis the Establishment clause. While the words are "Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion..." what they want it to mean is "Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of Christian religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." In other words what they mean by 'freedom of religion' is really, "freedom to practice the sect of Christianity you wish". But they don't mean freedom of religion.
Ultimately, if this community center doesn't get built both groups of fanatics-Christian and Muslim--will get precisely what it is they are hoping for. I can think of no greater memorial to those who were sacrificed at the altar of intolerance than to build this community center.