American Idol Fan Club

[The Oopster]

Originally Posted by Arwen

First singer made me cringe and nearly FF through the performance.
The first duet made me smile but it was not that good really. LOL

Haven't seen the rest. Not saying who though.

Bo answered my question of who was first! Tivo didn't record for some reason last night so watch them online today! Sure is a hell of a lot quicker! even when I use my tivo advantage!

Originally Posted by ~Bo

Yeah........that was Jacob and I thought he was pukey too. And what was that dancing he was doing?????
The whole show made me YAAAAAAWN too..........except for some of the duets.

I miss Pia.

Originally Posted by The_Lady_Snow

I was not impressed by ANYONE!!!!

I have never watched on my computer so maybe that is why they didn't look as bad, however I don't know if I was really impressed either.

I thought Haley actually had one of her best nights!

Although I think casey is very talented sometimes I wonder if his growling style is actually singing! Still think he'll be safe!

I did like Scotty's "you've got a friend" and wouldn't be surprised if they don't sell a lot of those! With that said I thought he was really off in the duet so he might not be safe from the bottom 3 but I think he is safe from being eliminated.

I hope Jacob is gone this time ... although I think Lauren had a really really weak night ... I think he was worse and has consistently been that way! Maybe i'm just not a fan of the gospel style who knows!

I thought James was decent but wasn't blow away! Felt sorry that he was paired with Jacob for the duet! I thought his side was good but being with Jacob could hurt him!

I'd definitely but Jacob and Lauren in the bottom 3! Not sure who the other one will be! I'm thinking it might be Casey!